Opinions about disqualification RB members

Feb 12, 2010

There are a few opinions about disqualification of PSL our members.

|RB|Honzik1

I do not like the behavior of man who does not respect the strict rules. I thought that the PSL is a competition where is mainly fun but now I do not think so. Almost everyone can see how anyone can accuse another because of cheating without the evidence needed. We published only in an embarrassing video where you can see only experienced game of player. But this suggests that the admin does not act lawfully against others and gives the impression that it all might think. And one month ago FK stop playing too, because there were no chance to change Shmutz wrong decision. From that moment I began to think that the PSL I will stop playing. I do not want to be the next target for admin charges. If you saw the game Majikal vs Drakas map campo, you could see that the admin has ordered replay game just because Drakas didnt know a map well and could not find an opponent. But no rule not allow to use this tactic. Look at this screenshot.

Finally, we were charged as well. I didn't play the qualifications just because I occupied the first four places. I played just to increase the qualification chances for the win one of our players. On the PSL official site you can see completely distorted information. Shmutz says that I deliberately stopped playing when the score was 23-11 but that is a big lie. When you look at the demo of the game, you'll see that I stopped playing about 20 seconds before the end of game. At this time I had difference about 5 frags. Shmutz written as the final score 24-23 but that is lie. I began to think that Shmutz is most of his time drunk. Each of us saw that admins finally started the game on face-capture map but they wrote the wrong name of the map (face_capture) and it took them about 10 minutes before the game really began. Shmutzwurst told me that I will be banned from all games next qualification and I can’t change his decision. About 3 days after qualification he said that he will change his decision about punishment. Here you can see that Shmutz is really a serious man. (Irony). RB team broke no rules and that is paramount. Shmutz "live decisions" are just for laugh. His "live decisions" make game not serious. "Live decisions" mean that admin can do everything what does he wants. If Shmutz is so lazy and he cannot write this rule "When it becomes clear that the player deliberately lost game and help second player to win, both players will be punished". It's his fault. But this rule has no sence. In many sports you are not punished if you give up game. For these reasons I will not play PSL anymore. This is my personal opinion and I am not alone who thinks so (not only RB players).


}JG{BeatZ

If anything happens what they don't want to happen and they don't have any rule which forbids it they have to add the rule and to punish next time. www.4pfel.net/jg (they will publish soon (few days) officialy)


sp4nk|Thomas

Banning is a bit too much, but he's right, it's not good to let other clanmates win.


|RB|deGrave

We were training many times, the win on douze depends on lucky. We fair pass to qualification so on.


/pCc/sospiro

In my opinion (good or not) sauerbraten is a game, I play it just for fun and my goal isn't be the best player but only fun. I play in a clan to have fun. After the clan is a team, and sauerbraten become a team-game.... then it needs teamwork. The act of let a player win (in the same team or no) in my opinion isn't ot be classified as illegal gaming because if in a football game let the opponent player win no one can say something against the team.... maybe someone can say is stupid ma no one can say it is illegal... they didn't do nothing illegal... by the way the opponent team in this case is a teammate of the player then it is a teamwork (always in my opinion) not illegal... honzik preferred pass the insta qualification than the ffa qualification, I think is the same as if he left the game. Secondly, no rule of PSL say it isn't possible then no one can say it's illegal.

In my opinion the act of let the teammate win can be considerate a bit stupid by someone but is true that happend in the sport too but the disqualification I think is a bit excesive in my opinion, cause is the first time, they didn't know was wrong for psl do it and they didn't know was wrong for psl and they were in the same team.


{QS}PunDit

In my opinion if it is something that is not in the rules and they disagree there should be no punishment and the rules should be immediately changed.


{QS}mos (about Shmutz's decision in Drakas vs Majikal game)

This is very good reminders why I don't play PSL. Thank you all.


|RB|Mewel

In my opinion if it is something that is not in the rules and they disagree there should be no punishment and the rules should be immediately changed.

Comments (0)